Eminent historian BD Chattopadhyaya passed away recently. Go through this article to understand his contribution.

Also, expect a question related to Early Medieval this year, esp the debate surrounding it's characterization as Feudal Age, it's economy as well as Emergence of Rajputs.

https://thewire.in/history/bd-chattopadhyaya-early-medieval-india-obituary

#feudalism #earlymedieval #historian #historyinnews #historiography #debate

Factors which paved the way for the rise of feudalism in India:

1. The concept of Dharma Vijaya, which was first mentioned in Arthashastra. In other words, Shakas, Kushanas, Guptas avoided complete annexation of defeated Kings, rather, they were allowed to rule as subordinated. This definitely created a hierarchy.

2. External invasions led to political fragmentations, viz. Hun invasions and Turkish invasions.

3. Land grants.

4. Decline in trade & commerce and money economy at least in some parts of the Indian subcontinent.


Features of Indian feudalism:

1. Political fragmentation and increased number of subordinate kings.

2. Rise of intermediaries between King and cultivators.

3. Emergence of overlord and subordinate peasantry. Overlords claimed a large part of the agrarian surplus on account of their supposed ownership of land and peasant-cultivator obliged to such exploitation on account of his loyalty to tradition and customs.

4. Landlordism was associated even with temples and monasteries.

5. In at least some of the land grants, peasants and craftsmen were tied with the land. So, they were transferred to the donees along with land. This resulted into feudalisation of agriculture and crafts, also known as Jajmani system.

6. Some of the big feudal lords started to give a part of their grant to subordinate chiefs. Thus, started the subinfeudation (hierarchy of lords).

7. Some of the grantees had military obligation to meet.

8. Feudal consciousness had been expressed in contemporary art and religion also.

Differences between European and Indian Feudalism:

1. Serfdom and manorial system were absent in India.

2. In the European context, feudalism was a phase which emerged out of the slave based economic production model i.e. a slave based economy to a serf based economy. In India, slaves existed but they were mainly deployed within household. Slave based production system was absent in India.

#feudalism #earlymedieval

Answer Writing Practice
Paper I: 13. Early Medieval India, 750-1200:

Question 1:
Trace the characteristic features of Chola kingship on the basis of inscriptions.

#Earlymedieval #Chola #Polity #inscription #AnswerWritingPractice

@nikhilhistoryoptional

Answer Writing Practice
Paper I: 13. Early Medieval India, 750-1200:

Answer 1:

Sources: Inscriptions to be mentioned in the answer
a. Prashastis - Tiruvalangad Copper Plates, Larger Leiden Plates and the Anbil Plates, Kanya Kumari Inscription of Vira Rajendra etc
b. Numerous Land Grant Inscriptions - first section called Meykirtis
c. Temple inscriptions - Uttaramerur, Tanjavur
--------------------------
There are generally three typical aspects about the Chola state. You should use them to construct the answer.
a. Nature of Chola state - centralized, segmentary, feudal, early state
b. Structure of Chola administration from top to bottom
c. Local self government under Cholas
------------------------------------------
Generic type Intro
Imperial Cholas rose to eminence in the 9th c CE when Vijayalaya seized Tanjavur from Pallavas and greatly spread during the era of Rajaraja and Rajendra who succeeded in creating a huge empire spanning entire South India and influencing even SE Asia.

Historiographical Intro
Nature of kingship in imperial Chola has been subjected to the great controversy due to the differing paradigms suggested by scholars like Nilkanth Shastri, Burten Stein, Karashima and Subbarayulu.
------------------------------------------
Additional Pointers
a. Legitimization - Sangam era legacy - names of earlier kings

b. Dominance of Sanskritic and Brahmanic traditions
i. Itihasa-Puranic tradition - Suryavamshi origin (Mythical origin in genealogies)
ii. Kshatriya origin - Varman suffix to various Chola kings
iii. Dharmopadeshaka - another title
iv. Hiranyagarbha and Tulabhara ceremonies

c. Achievements publicized
i. Mention of wars and military exploits of kings
ii. Various land grants

d. Example - Rajaraja Chola brought various feudatories under control, landed magnates incorporated into state system
i. Kshatriyashikhamani title to Rajaraja
ii. Gifts to meritorious Brahmins - to create support base.
iii. Title such as Ulakananda Perumal (Trivikrama who measured Earth) to Rajaraja

#Earlymedieval #Chola #Polity #inscription #AnswerWritingPractice

@nikhilhistoryoptional

Answer Writing Practice
Paper I: 13. Early Medieval India, 750-1200:

Question 2:
Discuss the role of women in politics in the Early Medieval era.

#Earlymedieval #women #gender #social #AnswerWritingPractice
@nikhilhistoryoptional

Answer Writing Practice
Paper I: 13. Early Medieval India, 750-1200:

Answer 2
Introduction 1:
Notwithstanding the patriarchal nature of society, the political history of early medieval India gives several instances of queens succeeding to the throne.

Introduction 2:
The political domain remained essentially masculine, but women worked in different capacities which marked a specific feature of gender relation in the early medieval period.

Introduction 3:
The Brahmanical literature in the Early Medieval favoured males and denied women public roles of authority. Other texts like Rajtarangini however not only highlight the women sovereign rulers but also of women’s agency behind the throne.
-------------------------------------------
Kashmir Examples:
Three female rulers of Kashmir (Yashovati, Sugandha and Didda of Gonda, Utpala and Yashakara dynasties respectively)

Odisha Examples: (Bhauma-Kara dynasty)
Prithivimahadevi ascended the throne at the behest of feudatories. Dandimahadevi, Dharmamahadevi, and Valkulamahadevi were other Bhauma-Kara queens.

Deccan and South Indian Examples:
🔸Eastern Chalukyas, Vijayamahadevi became ruler after the death of her husband. She is known to have issued a land grant to Brahmanas.

🔸A Kadamba queen named Divabbarasi is known to have ruled till her minor son attained majority. She too made land grants.

🔸Rudramadevi was a 13th-century Kakatiya queen of Andhra who succeeded to the throne on being nominated by her father.
-------------------------------------------
Other Political Roles:
🔸Besides the rulers, a large number of women also participated actively in court politics in different capacities as queen, princesses, low caste wives, concubines and servant girls.
🔸Besides these royal women, courtesans, temple dancers, wives, mothers and widows were also depicted as playing important roles in court politics.
🔸Besides politics, some royal and non-royal women were also shown patronizing religious buildings and other activities.
🔸Besides being rulers, some of the royal women were appointed as governors, administrators, village chieftain, counselor etc.
🔸Cross-cousin marriages and matrimonial alliances among royal families also allowed women to use their maternal connections politically and socially even after marriage.
-------------------------------------------
Conclusion 1:
Women’s participation in power politics did not remain uniform in the early medieval times. Various instances indicate that although political power in early medieval India was generally wielded by men, it could devolve on women in certain circumstances.

Conclusion 2:
However, the nature of society and state remained patriarchal in nature. The power these royal women exercised essentially remained subject to patriarchal norms.


#EarlyMedieval #Women #Gender #Social #AnswerWritingPractice
@nikhilhistoryoptional

Answer Writing Practice
Paper I: 14. Early Medieval India, 750-1200:

Question 3:
Throw light on the Bhakti of Alvar and Nayanar saints while underlining the significance of Bhakti movement in the history of South India. (250 words, 15 marks)

#Earlymedieval #bhakti #religion #south #dravida #tamil #AnswerWritingPractice

@nikhilhistoryoptional

Answer Writing Practice
Paper I: 14. Early Medieval India, 750-1200

Pointers for Answer 3
Part I
Introduce 12 Alwar, 63 Nayanar saints
Fused element of love and devotion reflected in sangam with bhakti based on Puranas in north India

Part II - Significance
🔺Organized popular movement - not only religious equality but also social equality
🔺Tamil language and literature
🔺Temples
🔺Revitalized North
🔺Strengthening Brahmanism (Vaishnava Acharya)
🔺Strengthening monarchy (eg Cholas)

#EarlyMedieval #bhakti #religion #south #dravida #tamil #AnswerWritingPractice
@nikhilhistoryoptional

Answer Writing Practice
Paper I: 14. Early Medieval India, 750-1200

Question 4
Evaluate Rajtarangini as a source of history. [2012, 10m]

#EarlyMedieval #Literature #Kashmir #Historiography #Sources #AnswerWritingPractice
@nikhilhistoryoptional

Answer Writing Practice
Paper I: 14. Early Medieval India, 750-1200

Pointers for Answer 4
Comment - In this answer, do not focus much on the content of Rajtarangini. What it tells about Kashmir is less relevant. What is more important is the approach of Kalhana to history writing. Assessment of his idea of history and also the sources he assessed and utilized, the way he provided information, all these are more relevant to this answer.
———————————————
Rajatarangini Basic Facts
Chronicle of Kashmir region, written in Sanskrit
Consists of eight books/tarangas composed in verse
First three tarangas deal with the history of the region till the 7th century CE
Tarangas 4 to 6 carry the story forward till the 11th century
Last two tarangas (which are also the longest) deal with the 12th century
———————————————
Rajtarangini = Only one History book from ancient India?
• Since the time of William Jones, it has been repeatedly said that there was only one text from early India that could be regarded as historical writing: the Rajatarangini, a history of Kashmir written by Kalhan in 1148. Kalhan describes it as a kavya.
———————————————
Kalhana is aware of representing the past “as it was”, as itihasa.
• Unlike many other chronicles, Kalhana takes care to mention the sources that he has consulted. The work shows a familiarity not only with the Epics and Puranas, but with more historically-oriented writing, such as the historical biographies written by Bana, by Bilhana, an important local Purana (Nilamata Purana), and Ksemendra’s Nrpavali. Various local inscriptions, coin legends were consulted, and oral tradition preserved in popular legends were also utilized.

• Kalhana was familiar with court circles (his father Champaka was the minister in the court of the earlier king), even if not serving at the court himself. This distancing probably enabled him to make independent judgements on various rulers. Kalhana was not writing to pamper any particular patron.

• He is also concerned with understanding the inexplicable behaviour of kings just prior to the current dynasty. Hence, his criticism of the actions of kings who were his close contemporaries. His narrative is peppered with severe judgements on various groups who exploited Kashmir.

• The text narrates the history of Kashmir and incorporates into the narration legends, chronology based on written records, and details of events closer to the author’s time which are more authentic. He claims that he is correcting the chronology of his predecessors and giving a connected account of the past by partly filling in gaps and removing fictitious genealogies.
———————————————
#EarlyMedieval #Literature #Kashmir #Historiography #Sources #AnswerWritingPractice
@nikhilhistoryoptional

Mention of Diwali in Al Beruni's Kitab up Hind.

#traveller #literature #earlymedieval

@nikhilhistoryculture